Evaluating Your Spooky Season Marketing: What Worked, What Didn’t, and How to Prepare for Next Year
How to use analytics from this year to grow your seasonal business and compound next year’s revenue.

With a sigh that sounds like dry leaves skittering along pavement, you watch another Spooky Season crest and recede in the rearview mirror. October has come and gone, and your seasonal business has completed its haunting run. Congratulations, you made it! But there’s no rest for the wicked. As the fog settles and the dust begins to clear, now is the best time to analyze the effectiveness of this year’s marketing efforts. Fine-tuning your marketing strategy for next year based on this year’s results is the entrepreneurial version of mapping out which neighbors passed out full-sized candy bars. In this post Spooky Season marketing evaluation, we’ll explore how to use analytics and other tools to gain insights and make data-driven decisions for next Spooky Season. 

The Post-Season Evaluation Timeline

Before diving into the marketing evaluation process, let’s establish a timeline as a guide, beginning .

Immediately Post-Spooky Season

  • Collect Data: Begin collecting data on various aspects of your business and marketing efforts. This includes ticket sales, website traffic, social media engagement, and any other relevant metrics.
  • Gather Feedback: Reach out to your team, employees, and customers to collect their immediate feedback and insights. What went well? What could have been better?

Within 2-4 Weeks After Spooky Season

  • Analyze Data: Dive deep into the data you’ve collected. Look for trends, patterns, and key performance indicators (KPIs). Pay special attention to conversion rates, revenue, and ROI.
  • Conduct Customer Surveys: Send out surveys to your customers, asking for their opinions and suggestions. 

1-2 Months After Spooky Season

  • Review Partnerships and Collaborations: If you engaged in partnerships or collaborations, evaluate their impact on your marketing and overall success. Did they bring in new customers?
  • Assess Budget Allocation: Review how you allocated your marketing budget and assess whether it was effectively distributed to the right channels and strategies.
  • Competitor Analysis: Analyze what your competitors did during Spooky Season. This can help identify areas where you might need to improve or expand.

3-4 Months After Spooky Season

  • Plan for Next Year: Use the insights from your analysis to finesse the marketing plan for the following Spooky Season. Make adjustments based on what you’ve learned.
  • Get Customer Feedback: Let last year’s customers know what you’re doing to improve this year, and ask for their input; there’s still time to course correct if trends are changing, or competitors are driving the industry in a new direction. 

Leveraging Analytics in Marketing

Analytics tools are crucial for assessing the performance of your marketing efforts. Consider using the following metrics.

  • Website Traffic: Measure the increase in website visitors during your marketing campaigns. Identify which ads, pages, or content attracted the most attention, and which ones converted visitors to sales or subscribers. Use advanced tracking of things like heat mapping, bounce rate, and rage clicks to improve the usability of your website so that it results in a higher conversion rate next year.
  • Conversion Rates: Assess how many website visitors turned into paying customers, and the source of those customers so you can double down on only the sources that result in sales. Look at landing page and sales funnel performance and implement tweaks. 
  • Social Media Engagement: Track the likes, shares, comments, and click-through rates on your social media posts. Identify which platforms and content resonated most with your audience, and which were a waste of time.
  • Email Marketing: Analyze open rates, click-through rates, and conversion rates for your email campaigns. Evaluate the effectiveness of subject lines, content, and calls to action.
  • Online Advertising: Review the ROI for paid advertising campaigns. Identify which ad platforms and relationships performed best.
  • Print Marketing: Although print marketing is harder to track than digital, it’s even more important to carefully analyze its ROI, as print marketing usually comes with higher up-front costs. 

The Customer is Always Fright

Customer feedback helps you understand the user experience and make improvements. When crafting your surveys, consider asking questions like:

  • How did you hear about our business?
  • What attracted you to our offerings?
  • Were there any aspects of our marketing that really resonated with you?
  • What can we do to enhance your experience next year?
  • Would you recommend our business to others?

Adjusting Your Marketing Strategy Post-Spooky Season

Once you’ve collected and analyzed your data, it’s time to make informed decisions for next year’s spooky season marketing strategy:

  • Double Down on What Works: If specific marketing channels or campaigns proved highly effective, allocate more resources to those areas in your next plan.
  • Tweak What Didn’t Work: Identify underperforming aspects of your marketing efforts and make necessary adjustments. Consider abandoning strategies that consistently yielded poor results, especially those that required major time or capital investments.
  • Listen to Customer Feedback: Take customer feedback seriously. Use it to enhance the customer experience and improve your marketing messaging.
  • Set Clear Goals: Establish specific, measurable, and achievable goals for your next spooky season. Define what success looks like and create a step-by-step roadmap to achieve it.
  • Stay Ahead of Trends: Stay informed about emerging marketing trends in your industry and apply them to your strategy for next year. Attend trade shows and subscribe to both B2B and competitor mailing lists. Don’t be afraid to experiment with new ideas.
  • Leverage Analytics for Networking: Update your press kit or affiliate program with the data you compiled from last year’s analytics, using these fresh numbers as lures for future media coverage or promo trades. 

Post-Spooky Season evaluation of your marketing effectiveness is an essential step in your ceaseless trek towards world domination, or even better, being able to miraculously take a week off. By leveraging this data, you can refine your marketing strategy and ensure that next Halloween is even more successful. Remember, learning from your past efforts is the key to making your spooky business even spookier in the future.

Want some guidance on how to use your analytics to grow your brand and compound next year’s revenue? Summon us for a free consultation on how to make next Spooky Season your most profitable one yet.

More articles